National Highway Traffic Safety Administration2019 Toyota HighlanderPowertrain
2019 Toyota Highlander XLE, 137K miles
ODI Happened June 18, 2026Filed September 29, 2026
In the owner's words
2019 Toyota Highlander XLE, 137K miles. Always maintained, never any issues whatsoever, family loved our 'forever' car, UNTIL the dreaded whining noise began underneath the front floorboard. No warning, no indication, just started while driving on the highway and increasingly became louder over the two additional months I drove it. Quick online search indicates this is a very common issue. Brought to a local dealership in Southern NH, where it was quickly diagnosed as a failing transmission in need of replacement. No warranty, out of pocket cost approx. $8K. Just so happened they had a spare, remanufactured transmission already in house, since this was becoming a 'common issue'. They even had what sounded like a dedicated technician that did at least one replacement a week and had the repair time down to a science. No other warning signs, no software codes, no jerking or slipping while driving, just the noise that increased as the gas pedal was pressed. Well known issue, yet no recall for the 2019 year. Toyota forums indicate the replacement transmissions fail as well after accumulating some miles, which might explain why they only offered me a 1-yr warranty if I had replaced mine. It's for this reason I traded in this Highlander vehicle, as this vehicle was no longer safe or suitable for any long distance family driving. It was also my wife's primary vehicle to transport my young daughters, and I believed that the Highlander would have soon left them stranded. I even purchased AAA tow service for the first time in my life at [XXX], all because of this known transmission issue. I now warn everyone who is searching for this SUV to be very aware. INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
An owner's report to NHTSA. NHTSA reads every complaint to decide what to investigate; it doesn't verify them, and a complaint is not a recall.